Fact or Fiction:
Screenwriting Myths Debunked

By Karlanna Lewis 

Whether you have already written and even sold a number of screenplays, or you are embarking on your first screenwriting adventure, be wary of the bounty of screenwriting advice available from well-meaning “experts.”

Take any advice, including the following, with a heaping teaspoon of salt. As the Buddha said, “believe nothing, no matter where you read it, or who said it…unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.”

1. Your idea will get stolen.

Myth: Execution of a script idea, not the idea itself, makes a movie, so don’t worry about theft of concept.

Also, contrary to popular belief, most producers are perfectly willing to acquire material legally. And if registered script is stolen, you should receive help in court. Don’t be rush to sue, though, because writers who file lawsuit for theft often lose.

2. Write a screenplay to appeal to the four-quadrant demographic: the young, the old, men and women.

Myth: Write a movie you love, not a movie you think the market will like. Don’t add random elements or extra characters solely to broaden a movie’s appeal; all you will do is alienate the target audience. Instead, focus on including “re-watchable moments,” scenes the target audience enjoys so much they return to see the film over and over (these moments sell oft-criticized single quadrant romantic comedies).

Remember also the first people who need to like your film are producers and agents, but don’t waste time playing the guessing game of what their personal tastes may be.

3. Signing a release signs your rights away.

Myth: Often a release form (either provided by the reviewing company or written yourself) is necessary to get screenplays read. Include response expectations, whether you are submitting elsewhere and a clause specifying your retention of copyright.

4. A writer should have complete creative control over the screenplay.

Myth: Neither the writer or director should have full control. Film is collaborative, and writers must be open to making changes in their scripts. However a production company cannot ethically ask a Writers Guild member to change a screenplay without payment.

5. Write what you know.

Half-myth: Writing what you know (or can research and learn) makes for a believable screenplay, but if everyone followed this rule too many movies would portray struggling artists. Imagination is necessary to write fantastical and extraordinary films.

6. You must have industry connections.

Myth: Producers are also interested in new talent, and even first-timers can make big box-office runs. (Think of the strong critical and public reception for writer Diablo Cody’s debut, Juno.)

7. A rejected screenplay can be revised and resubmitted to the same company.

Myth: Most companies will only look at a screenplay once, so tweak carefully before that one-shot pitch.

8. Reading your pitch to the studio executives works.

Myth: Selling a script is one of the most important parts of a writer’s job. First, focus on producers and production companies because they are the real target decision-makers.

As you pitch, maintain eye contact and engage the listener in the presentation. Your script will have a much better shot at being picked up than through a verbatim reading.
Use framing techniques at the beginning to draw the listener in, but don’t waste time telling the listener how you got the story idea.

The written pitch can then be presented in a “leave behind,” a one-page treatment for producers to read after the writer has left. Proper treatments are brief, double-spaced, dialogue-free synopses.

9. Material trumps formatting.

Myth: As with many things, improper formatting can be a weeding out tool. Use proper spelling, punctuation and script guidelines to ensure your script is read. Always include scene headings, action, character names and dialogue, and keep a feature script between 90 and 100 double-spaced pages.

10. More money is available to independent films now than ever before.

True: With many burgeoning independent film festivals, from Sundance to Raindance, the time is ripe for indies.

Fade Out:

As a final note, consider the oft-discussed concept of turnaround. When a screenplay is abandoned by one company another production company may pick it up. While both E.T. and Forrest Gump rebounded well after a turnaround, the high fees required to repay development costs often mean a movie in turnaround will never get produced. Be wary.

So go forth, then, and write, and rewrite, keeping this advice in mind—but only so long as it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.

Your Comments Please


They all make perfect sense to me, except for #2. Yes, write what you love, but don't be afraid to experiment with what you've written to try to make it more marketable.
Ex 1: Putting a love interest into an action flick can make it appeal to women, as well as men. Almost all successful action flicks do this. (And please pardon the gender stereotypes, but the market does bear them out.)
Ex 2: Putting some cute young things into a flick whose leads are oldies but goodies will bring in more interest from the younger set, and provide a bit of eye candy in the process. Consider the supporting roles in GRUMPY OLD MEN and THE BEST EXOTIC MARIGOLD HOTEL.
Ex. 3: Finally, consider writing shorts and marketing them. It's usually a quicker route to getting produced. Besides, then you'll have your own demo reel and that much-needed exposure. Spielberg wrote and produced 3 shorts before he found the resources to direct his first low-budget feature. Not a bad role model to learn from.

-Mary Huckstep




I enjoyed Karlanna's article, though I had already guessed most of the points. I liked the link to a clip from ET. I think this was Spielberg's best film -- such imagination and humanity!

I am working on a biopic about Osho, formerly Bhagwan Shree Rajneesh, the 20th century Indian mystic. It is called 'The Orange Buddha.'


John Nygate


Send your comments, please: click here

Casting Your Film

Learn about the casting process and the best ways to get the right actors for your production.

Tutors: Rory O'Donnell Venue: Raindance Film Centre
10 Craven Street, WC2N 5PE
Date: April 9 Duration: Single Eveninng
Time: 6:30pm - 9:30pm Price: £48

For Raindance Premium Members Discounts log into the Members Area

About The Author

Karlanna Lewis Karlanna Lewis, whose dreams include becoming a bird, completed her honors B.A. in Russian and Creative Writing at Florida State University in spring 2011, with an honors thesis in poetry and minor in computer science.

At Florida State Ms. Lewis was selected as an Outstanding Senior Scholar. As a graduate student at Florida State Ms. Lewis was a 2011-12 Rhodes Scholar Finalist.

She has also presented a research project on Russian literature and dance at various conferences. Ms. Lewis is a published writer and galleried artist, and in August 2011 she published her first book, Cante de Gitanas con Nombres de Luz / Songs of the Gypsies with Names of Light.

A native of Tallahassee, Florida, Ms. Lewis is a principal dancer for the Pas de Vie Ballet and has led an honors service project teaching dance to local schoolchildren. Ms. Lewis has worked multiple jobs as a cashier, teacher, and journalist her entire collegiate career and volunteered as a DJ and the continuity director for the V89 radio station.

Now as an intern at Raindance Film Festival in London, Ms. Lewis is writing articles about film, assisting with Web building projects and translating the Web site into Russian. When she leaves Raindance at the end of April she will spend a month in France as a writer-in-residence at Camac Art Centre.

In the future she plans to pursue her M.F.A. in creative writing and to eventually become a university professor. Serving as an art director for a production team is her ideal film job. Passionate about the arts and the environment, in 2011 she founded the non-profit Dancearth, an arts for social change initiative celebrating movement and the earth in which we move.

Check out her website: karlannalewis.com

If You Liked This, You'll Really Like...

Free Article: 12 Most Important Films of 2012
Free Article: 5 Reasons Myth-Based Movies Work
Free Article: 5 Film Bloggers To Follow

Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter
Watch independent shorts, features and documentaries on www.raindance.tv
Submission details to Raindance Film Festival
Visit us on Twitter for daily tips and updates 

© 2012 Raindance Ltd.
Reproduction of this article without written permission is strictly forbidden. For information on reprint rights please email info@raindance.co.uk

Fact of Fiction: Screenwriting Myths Debunked